Talent Edge Weekly - Issue #373

Why judgment matters more in AI-enabled early-career work, how org design and technology may contribute to excess workloads, testing demand before hiring, Wharton’s State of Succession Planning report, and a new review of hiring assessment research.

SPONSORED BY

Welcome to the new issue of Talent Edge Weekly!

First, a shout-out to Christine Johnson, Director of Organizational Capability & Talent COE at Acumatica, for referring new subscribers to Talent Edge Weekly. Thank you, Christine, for your support of this newsletter!

 Not subscribed to Talent Edge Weekly? Sign up now and get 5 of my PDFs.

PRESENTED BY TalentNeuron

AI is reshaping work, but the economics of AI are shifting too. As the business landscape changes, workforce leaders face some difficult decisions:

  • Where should you invest in people, and where should you put AI to work?

  • Which skills and roles will matter as the pace of AI adoption changes?

  • When should you build skills, hire new talent, or redesign the work itself?

Hear how leaders from BCG, Siemens, RTX and CodeSignal are answering them at TalentNeuron Live 26: The Future of Workforce Design on November 18 at 9 AM ET / 2 PM GMT / 3 PM CET. Half a day, virtual and free.

On the agenda:

  • TalentNeuron CEO David Wilkins and Kyle Lagunas of Kyle & Co. on where workforce design goes next

  • Sandra Nowak of Siemens and Bob Motion of RTX on the workforce decisions in front of them now

Plus, be among the first to see what TalentNeuron is launching in 2027.

THIS WEEK'S CONTENT

Below are links and descriptions of the topics covered in this issue. If you're interested in my deep dive, you can read the full newsletter.

Also, check out my job cuts tracker & Chief HR Officer move of the week, which is an excerpt from my CHROs on the Go platform. 

My Private Community, Talent Edge Circle 

Talent Edge Circle is my private community for internal HR practitioners who shape and execute talent strategy. You pressure-test your thinking with me and peers working on similar challenges, live and online, so you can turn your talent priorities into business value faster.

Applications for November have closed, and I am now accepting applications for a few spots starting December 1st. Apply now. Applications will not reopen until January 2027.

Ready to be part of the Circle?

Now let’s dive in.

Brian Heger
Follow Me on LinkedIn

THIS WEEK'S EDGE 

AI AND EARLY-CAREER TALENT

A new 31-page report explores how AI is changing early-career work, including the growing importance of judgment and how we define, develop, and test this critical capability.

Last week, I shared my one-pager illustrating how increased reliance on AI can erode existing skills and limit future skill development, including for early-career workers. For early-career workers, one reason this happens is that AI increasingly absorbs the routine tasks that, through repeated exposure and practice, help develop certain capabilities, such as judgment. This new 31-page report builds on this theme, drawing on 1M+ entry-level tech job postings and discussions with 54 practitioners. It describes what it calls a consequence gap: as AI makes it easier to produce work that looks right, value shifts from producing the work to recognizing, anticipating, and managing its consequences. As one practitioner put it, “You can prompt an AI system all day and it will build the wrong thing.” That is where judgment comes in. One insight I want to highlight from the report is that practitioners used different terms and descriptors for judgment, from turning ambiguous asks into clear requirements to weighing tradeoffs. It raises an important question: Has your organization clearly defined what good judgment means in this context and the observable behaviors that demonstrate it? Once those capabilities and behaviors are defined, organizations can more intentionally embed them into hiring criteria, development experiences, and other talent practices and decisions. The report also shares how some employers are experimenting with different ways to test judgment, such as having workers explain a project and their decisions to a live panel or talk through an unfamiliar case in real time.

WORKFORCE CAPACITY & PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT

A new research paper examines how organization design, reporting relationships, and technology can push workloads beyond capacity. I also reshare my one-pager on goal creep.

With about six week left in the calendar year, many organizations are refining and/or finalizing workforce plans and performance objectives. Yet hidden factors can undermine sound plans. One is goal creep, when new goals get added without adjusting existing commitments or resources. When this is not managed intentionally, work demands can quietly outstrip available capacity. In my one-page resource, I shared six questions to help teams recalibrate performance goals, priorities, and capacity when new work is added throughout the year. Building on this issue, a new academic paper examines another threat to capacity: how organization design, technology, and reporting relationships intensify workloads. The authors examine: 1) Matrix structures: Multiple managers assign work to the same employee without accounting for competing demands (e.g., a functional manager and project manager assign priorities to one employee). 2) Vertical hierarchies: Managers at different levels add requests to the same employee (e.g., a senior leader requests an urgent analysis while the direct manager adds deliverables). Each request may seem reasonable, but together they can exceed capacity, reduce productivity, and contribute to burnout. Technology can amplify this by letting more managers assign and monitor work directly. As organizations revisit governance and decision rights amid AI-enabled workflows, they can also use this opportunity to clarify who reconciles competing demands. Meanwhile, any manager or leader can ask their direct report: “What work are others asking of you, and which goals or work should we reprioritize or recalibrate?”

WORKFORCE PLANNING & TALENT ACQUISITION

My one-pager with 12 example questions to help leaders test whether additional hiring is needed or whether other talent options can meet the need.

Strategic workforce planning (SWP) is consistently ranked as a top priority by HR leaders. Yet it has one of the largest gaps between ranked importance and organizational capability. One costly result of ineffective SWP is a familiar cycle: organizations hire aggressively based on optimistic or insufficiently tested assumptions, lay people off when workforce supply exceeds demand, and then rehire when demand returns or essential capabilities prove harder to replace than expected. Not every workforce reduction is evidence of overhiring. But when organizations repeatedly hire, cut, and rehire for similar work, it is a signal to examine whether demand assumptions, work design, capacity planning, and talent alternatives are being sufficiently tested before costly workforce decisions are made. To help leaders identify where this risk may be building, I created a simple “Before You Add Headcount” diagnostic covering demand signals, work and capacity signals, and talent-alternative signals. Instead of asking only, “Do we need more people?” leaders can ask: “What work needs to be done, what is driving the need, and what is the best way to meet that work demand?” Testing these three signal areas before hiring enables leaders to make better and more informed talent decisions.

SUCCESSION PLANNING

A new 38-page report examines succession planning, from organizational readiness to internal mobility. I also share a few of my previous one-pagers to help put these insights into practice.

Succession planning continues to be a top talent priority, making it important to assess where practices can improve. Against this backdrop, this new 38-page publication draws on a survey of 2,544 business leaders across seven markets and features insights from Wharton professors Peter Cappelli, Matthew Bidwell, Emilie Feldman, and Henning Piezunka. Among its many insights, here are three I want to highlight, alongside a few of my one-pagers I have previously shared to help put them into practice. 1) Organizational readiness: Beyond evaluating whether successors are ready, the report emphasizes whether the organization itself is prepared for a transition. Even a ready successor may struggle if critical knowledge and relationships reside with the departing leader, risking business continuity. Questions to consider include: Is critical knowledge documented and shared? Are key relationships dependent on one leader? Can important decisions continue without that leader? This type of organizational readiness risk can also be added as another consideration in my critical-role risk assessment. 2) Internal mobility: Talent hoarding and restrictive policies, including manager approval requirements, can weaken successor pipelines. My talent hoarding diagnostic, which managers can use for self-reflection, and my mobility barriers checklist offer ways to identify potential obstacles. 3) Keeping plans current: Changing business conditions can make succession plans outdated. My nine off-cycle triggers provide examples of when plans might warrant reassessment.

HIRING ASSESSMENTS

A new academic review of 20 meta-analyses finds the evidence behind common hiring assessments is weaker than often assumed, and offers a checklist for evaluating it.

A new research paper published in the International Journal of Selection and Assessment examines the strength of the evidence on how well commonly used hiring assessments predict job performance. Through a review of 20 meta-analyses covering interviews, cognitive ability tests, personality assessments, and other selection methods, the researchers identify limitations in the underlying studies. For example, only 2 of the 20 meta-analyses were based exclusively on actual job applicants. Most were based primarily on existing employees or did not report this information, and existing employees’ motivation and behavior may differ from applicants’ when employment is at stake. Other concerns include limited information needed to estimate validity in actual hiring settings and assumptions used to address gaps in the data. These findings do not mean the assessments are ineffective, but they raise questions about how confidently their reported validity applies to actual hiring decisions. As an additional practical resource, Table 2 provides a checklist for evaluating the quality of assessment validation studies. A few questions HR practitioners can draw from it include: 1) Was the assessment tested with actual applicants? 2) How was subsequent job performance measured? 3) Is the evidence relevant to the jobs and candidate populations we are hiring for? 4) Was the sample size large enough to support the conclusions? These questions can help us critically evaluate the evidence supporting hiring assessments rather than taking claims of predictive validity at face value.

MOST POPULAR FROM LAST ISSUE

AI’S IMPACT ON SKILLS

My one-pager on how AI can erode existing skills and limit future skill development, with questions to help HR practitioners address both risks.

JOB CUTS AND LAYOFF TRACKER

Check out my tracker of announcements from a segment of organizations that have conducted job cuts and layoffs since the start of 2023.

A few job cuts announced this past week:

  • Boeing (NYSE: BA). The aerospace giant plans to cut about 5% of its Commercial Airplanes workforce, or roughly 2,500 positions, through layoffs and attrition. The company is slowing planned production increases for the 737 MAX and 787, with layoff notices starting in December.

  • PepsiCo (NASDAQ: PEP). The food and beverage giant is cutting about 1,000 jobs across its North America business to simplify its structure and speed up decision-making. The cuts follow a lowered full-year earnings outlook amid sluggish soda sales and weaker snack demand.

  • PVH (NYSE: PVH). The apparel company behind Calvin Klein and Tommy Hilfiger plans to reduce its global workforce by about 4%, or around 12% of office-based roles. The cuts mainly affect non-consumer-facing positions as part of an initiative to improve productivity and long-term profitability.

Click here to access my tracker, which includes all announcements.

CHIEF HR OFFICER MOVE OF THE WEEK

This past week, several new CHRO announcements were posted on CHROs on the Go, my digital platform tracking movement in and out of the CHRO role. 

This week’s highlight is:

  • Authority Brands (COLUMBIA, MARYLAND) — a multi-brand home services franchisor — appointed Whitney Woodward Chief People Officer. Woodward most recently served as Chief People Officer at Employbridge, leading the people function for more than 2,000 colleagues and supporting more than 350,000 associates annually. Previously, she was SVP and Chief People Officer at The Aaron's Company and spent 20 years at RaceTrac Petroleum, ultimately serving as VP of Human Resources.

 🔑 To access all detailed CHRO announcements from this past week and over 5,000 archived announcements, join CHROs on the Go. It’s the easiest way to stay informed about movement in and out of the Chief HR role.

If you are already a subscriber to CHROs on the Go, log in here.

My Private Community, Talent Edge Circle 

Talent Edge Circle is my private community for internal HR practitioners who shape and execute talent strategy. You pressure-test your thinking with me and peers working on similar challenges, live and online, so you can turn your talent priorities into business value faster.

Applications for November have closed, and I am now accepting applications for a few spots starting December 1st. Apply now. Applications will not reopen until January 2027.

Ready to be part of the Circle?

FROM ME ON LINKEDIN

Catch up on what you may have missed from me on LinkedIn:

Want to get your brand, product, or service in front of our active 60,000+ Talent Edge Weekly subscribers? Learn how to become a potential sponsor.

Brian Heger
Follow Me on LinkedIn

Talent Edge Weekly is written by Brian Heger, a human resources practitioner. You can connect with Brian on LinkedIn and brianheger.com

🗣️ WANT MORE?

Want access to all my curated resources?
👉️ Visit my website, brianheger.com

Are you an internal HR practitioner?
👉️ Apply for my private, paid community, Talent Edge Circle

Are you a provider of HR-related services?
👉️ Become a sponsor of Talent Edge Weekly

Want to know who’s moving in and out of the CHRO role?
👉️ Join my CHROs on the Go subscription